Five ways governments are responding to violence against women and children during COVID-19

While the world may have been caught off guard by the size and ramifications of the COVID-19 crisis, it should be prepared to respond to the increased risks to the wellbeing and safety of children and women. Violence against children and violence against women are widespread globally and intrinsically linked, sharing common risk factors and similar adverse and severe consequences. The literature within pandemics may be limited, but we have enough evidence to say unequivocally that related factors—such as confinement, social isolation, increased levels of financial stress, and weak institutional responses—can increase or intensify levels of violence.

Indeed, over the past month, reports have warned of the “perfect storm”, manifesting in increased calls to helplines, online support services, and police reports.

Indeed, over the past month, reports have warned of the “perfect storm”, manifesting in increased calls to helplines, online support services, and police reports. Multinational organisations quickly took action, issuing statements warning of increased risk of both forms of violence, while researchers reviewed evidence from past crises, proposing policy actions to mitigate against potential harm to populations in situations of vulnerability.

As governments ramp up response to COVID-19, what is actually being done to combat violence?

1. Expansion of helplines and information sharing

Information is being shared widely through guides, resources, and advocacy targeting friends and family members. Parenting for Lifelong Health has compiled evidence-supported guidance for safe parenting during quarantine. Helplines and online support platforms are being expanded or established. Italy, one of the countries hardest hit by the pandemic, is preventing “an emergency within an emergency” by advertising the 1522 helpline for violence and stalking. Numerous other countries are committing to keeping helplines and information channels open during and after the peak of COVID-19.

2. Funding shelters and other safe accommodation options for survivors

Numerous countries have acknowledged that additional safe housing is needed during times of quarantine. Safe accommodation allows survivors (and accompanying minors) to temporarily escape abusers. As part of its COVID-19 relief package, Canada has allocated $50 million to women’s shelters and sexual assault centres [March 18]. In France, a €1.1 million funding increase for anti-abuse organisations included 20,000 hotel nights for survivors to escape abusive partners [March 30]. In Trento (Italy), a prosecutor ruled that in situations of domestic violence the abuser must leave the family home rather than the victim [March 28]. Similar rulings have been given in Austria and Germany. Although a laudable decision, it makes guaranteeing the safety of survivors, who remain at home a challenge given that perpetrators know where to reach them and may have access to the home.

© UNICEF/UNI313118/AdelsonSixteen-year-old Julia attends online school from home while her parents telework during the Coronavirus outbreak in New York.

3. Expansion of access to services for survivors

As quarantine limits personal mobility and freedom of movement, some countries are finding ways to expand access to violence-related services. France has initiated ‘pop up’ centres in grocery stores, where women are likely to be already visiting [March 30]. In a number of countries (including France, Italy, and Spain), a specific ‘code word’ signals to pharmacies to contact the relevant authorities. Some countries have released or improved concealed apps through which women can seek services to avoid calling in close quarters with abusers (see Italy, UK, among others). Protection services for women and children must be considered “essential” and not locked down due to COVID-19. 

4. Limiting risk factors associated with violence

Some countries are tackling the negative ways of coping with COVID-19 that may exacerbate the risk of violence. Greenland has banned alcohol sales in its capital Nuuk to reduce the risk of violence against children in the home [March 29]. South Africa has taken similar measures [26 March]. While alcohol abuse and problematic drinking is shown to be linked to more severe violent episodes, the relationship is complex and there is limited evidence of how alcohol-related policies affect violence. Other countries, however, have yet to take proactive steps to limit associated risks. Curtailing gun sales, for example, would limit access to fatal weapons at a time of heightened stress, potentially reducing the risk of female homicide and child deaths. Smart policy action can reduce risk of harm and facilitate positive outlets to reduce stress and promote mental health.

5. Modifications to family law and justice systems

Australia has implemented a number of modifications to family law to allow the justice system to better respond to cases during quarantine [April 3]. First, they allow courts to impose electronic monitoring requirements for bail and conditionally suspend imprisonment orders. Second, they enable online filing of restraining orders. Third, they create a new offence, increased fine, and extended limitation period for restraining orders. As more countries experience extended periods of curtained justice services, further innovation and amendments are needed to ensure the protection of survivors in challenging situations.

These actions are commendable, however many countries have still not committed resources to increase services. Initial policy responses are largely in high-income countries, which may reflect the reality that many resource-poor settings have limited budgets for addressing violence against children and violence against women even when there is no crisis.

Where and how should resources be targeted? While reported cases and numbers from existing services give us a signal of what might be happening, they also give an imperfect picture. For example, in some settings, calls to domestic violence hotlines have decreased, possibly because survivors are in ear shot of perpetrators in quarantine and are unable to safely seek help. In others, demand for shelters has decreased, potentially because survivors are afraid of contracting COVID-19 within close quarters at shelters. In addition, some routine detection systems are closed, such as teachers or social workers. Already in the US, several states have reported reductions in child abuse and maltreatment, believed to be due to a reduction in detection, rather than occurrence.

Further, increased time spent on phones and using computers to communicate in place of in-person interactions also poses additional avenues for perpetration of new forms of violence online, including sexual harassment, exploitation, and abuse. Mitigation efforts must address the diverse forms of violence connected with COVID-19. Actions taken must be continuously monitored to ensure they are having intended effects, and do not result in unintended harm.

“For many women and girls, the threat looms largest where they should be safest. In their own homes.” As the UN Secretary-General urgently calls for peace in homes around the world, we hope that this non-exhaustive list of government responses will provide some inspiration for further action. When it comes to preventing and reducing violence and supporting survivors, everyone has a part to play, particularly in these unprecedented times.

 

Alessandra Guedes is the Gender & Development Research Manager at UNICEF Innocenti. Amber Peterman is a Social Policy Specialist with UNICEF Innocenti and University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Dina Deligiorgis is Policy Specialist on ending violence against women at UN Women.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with “required.”

Comments:

  1. Sería importante contar en Ecuador con la des burocratización de la política pública frente a la actuación en las acciones para lograr prevenir la violencia en todas sus formas y siendo la intrafamiliar y la violencia de género machista. Ecuador no nos ha garantizado a las mujeres verdaderos espacios de prevención y atención a las mujeres víctimas y a quienes somos parte de los equipos técnicos de atención. Contamos con una Ley de Violencia en Ecuador, pero duerme para este gobierno el sueño de los mudos. Me parece oportuno lograr la prohibición de venta de licores frente a bajar los indices de violencia en los sectores de mayor estado de vulneración social. Y poder lograr mitigar en parte la violencia en varios hogares frente al consumo de alcohol. En Esmeraldas desde FODIMUF se nos vulneró el derecho a seguir dando atención a Mujeres Víctimas de Violencia. La Secretaria de Derechos Humanos. Dejo fuera a la única organización en VIF.

  2. The govt needs to show zero tolerance all the way to throttle any ill device or motive to harass or violate child and women. Special acts above all ambiguous outlook should be devised so that no one can enjoy impunity. All existing laws are to be revised and new ones to be imposed on. Last but not the least, the govt has to draw a bottom line whether it will be committed to retaining the life and dignity of women and children in light of a more humane and modern setting of a society.

  3. Thanks for supporting the word with this message for preventing violence against women and girls in this covid19 situation. Let all governments around the world take it serious.

  4. These hard times bring much pain and suffering to many. In diffrent ways….they are doing their jobs to look into such reported findings. But when a single mother of 3 children gets the state called on them for false accusations. Should than the accusers/reporter or reporters be looked into as Well? For there are sure to be bad people out there in the world, making false reports all over the place to keep heat of some sort or any sort off their back….like illegal drug users that feel so bad about them selves for doing drugs and have lost everything they have and can’t stop using….only to blame a (straight sober,) single parent of 3. For using illegal drugs.because they are up all night cleaning the house and doing chores..We all as parents or caretakers of children ..well we know how hard it is to keep a place clean with children of all ages are present. So I do my cleaning and what not at night as well as through out the day..i have PTSD and multiple other issues that keep me awake at night…and …if this for instance happens…and the findings is truly straight up false….should than the case by state get dropped….as is most often the ” you wont hear from us any more ,last words, because there is no evadence. Nothing in the test….should than the accusers be looked into them selves???? Many many good hard working parents are being forced to admit to things they never did. And pay dues for crimes they never committed…..yet those that deserve to be punished or helped in maners they truly need….but are to deep to admit….further more shouldnt it be fair for both parties to be looked into..to rule out the he said she said dramma. I’m sure I dont have the only children that have fought and argued and throwed temper tantrum over this and that and that and this. Not being able to go play on the playground at the school…no school…no friends….no life…why can’t some people understand. that life for all is not perfect. I am one who appreceates being able to prove my innocence when it is stated that I’m at fault…yet I too have to issues accepting that I was wroung, when wrong…..cabin fever seems to be hitting people harder than the depression.

  5. It is so crucially important that women are provided a complete education and in this way giving them empowerment

  6. Se necesita una reglamentación detallada ante cada evento de violencia doméstica con la protección efectiva que se deberá dar rápidamente a la mujer

  7. Every community should be involved in preventing human trafficking and form strategies to help women and girls.

  8. This is good information. It has helped me in Counseling Psychology studies. Thanks a lot and continue keeping us posted.

  9. J’en suis ravi de connaitre la motivations des Etats et organisations pour s’adonner à lutter contre les violences à l’égard des enfants et des femmes en cette periode de pandémie à COVID-19 en mettant en place certaines dispositions juridiques et techniques à ce effet.